Why Do We Have a Favourite Spoon, Cup or Plate?

AI Image

Have you ever opened your kitchen cupboard, looked at a perfectly respectable collection of cups and still reached for one particular cup? Perhaps it is an old ceramic mug, a slightly chipped tea cup, or an ordinary steel glass that has been around for years. There may be ten other perfectly good cups sitting beside it, but somehow your morning tea tastes right only when it is served in that cup.

The same thing happens with spoons, plates and bowls. We develop preferences that seem rather irrational when we stop to think about them. We may have beautiful new crockery, bought with great enthusiasm, yet continue using the same old plate for breakfast. A particular spoon somehow feels just right in the hand. A bowl that has lost its shine is still the one we reach for when we want our favourite dal or kheer.

So what is going on here? Why do ordinary kitchen objects become so strangely important to us?

The answer has less to do with the object itself and much more to do with familiarity, our senses, memories and the small rituals through which we organise our everyday lives.

Familiarity is comforting

Our brains tend to feel comfortable with things that are familiar. A familiar object does not require us to think about it. We already know its weight, shape, texture and size. We know how it feels in our hand and, in the case of a cup or glass, roughly how much it holds.

Think about your favourite mug. You probably don't consciously analyse its dimensions every morning. You simply pick it up. Your hand already knows where the handle is and how to hold it. That familiarity makes the experience effortless.

The same principle explains why people become attached to their favourite chair, their usual place at the dining table or even the particular side of the bed on which they sleep. Familiar objects and routines create a sense of predictability, and predictability can be comforting in a life that is otherwise full of change.

Your hands remember too

Our relationship with kitchenware is not based only on what we see. Touch plays an important role as well.

A heavy ceramic mug feels different from a thin porcelain cup. A steel tumbler feels different from a glass. One spoon may have a handle that sits comfortably between your fingers while another may feel too light or too long.

After using an object repeatedly, our brains become familiar with these sensory details. We don't have to consciously remember them; our bodies simply recognise them.

This may explain why a new cup that looks much more attractive than your old one can somehow feel wrong. The new cup has not yet become part of your sensory memory. Your old cup has.

And then there are the memories

This is perhaps the most important reason an ordinary kitchen object can become special.

A cup may remind you of your mother. A steel plate may have been part of your childhood meals. Perhaps a particular spoon travelled with you when you moved into your first home. Maybe the cup was bought during a memorable holiday, or perhaps it was part of the crockery your parents received when they set up their home.

The object itself may have very little monetary value, but it has acquired something much more personal: a history.

This is also why people sometimes find it surprisingly difficult to throw away old household objects. Someone else may look at a chipped bowl and see something that should have gone into the bin years ago. You may look at exactly the same bowl and remember Sunday lunches with your family.

The bowl has not stored the memory inside itself. We have attached the memory to the bowl.

Can the cup actually change the taste of your tea?

There is a little science here too.

The experience of eating and drinking is not created by our taste buds alone. Our brains combine information from taste, smell, sight, touch and even our expectations to create what we experience as flavour.

The vessel can therefore influence our perception of food and drink. The shape of a cup can affect how its aroma reaches the nose. The size and appearance of a plate can influence our perception of portion size. The colour and presentation of crockery can also influence what we expect the food to taste like.

This doesn't mean that your grandmother's old cup contains some magical ingredient that makes tea better. But if that cup is associated with pleasant experiences, your brain may already expect the experience to be enjoyable.

So when you say, "My tea tastes better in this cup," you may not be imagining it. The cup is part of the whole sensory experience.

Our favourite objects become part of our rituals

Human beings are creatures of habit. We create small rituals without even noticing them.

Perhaps your morning begins with making tea, reaching for the same cup and sitting in the same chair near the window. Perhaps you use one particular bowl for your evening soup or a certain plate whenever you eat your weekend breakfast.

None of these actions is particularly important on its own. Together, however, they create a familiar rhythm.

This becomes especially obvious when we travel. A hotel may have perfectly good cups, plates and spoons, but after a few days we may begin to miss our own kitchen. It isn't necessarily because our crockery is superior. It is because those familiar objects are connected to our routines.

The cup at home belongs to our morning. The hotel cup is simply a hotel cup.

Children are not very different from us

Parents often notice that children can become extremely particular about their plates, glasses and spoons. One child may insist on eating from the red plate while refusing the blue one. Another may want the same bowl every evening.

Adults sometimes find this amusing, but we aren't necessarily that different. We simply express the preference in a more respectable way.

A child might say, "I want my red plate."

An adult might say, "I don't know why, but I just prefer this cup."

The underlying behaviour can be surprisingly similar. Both have developed an association between a familiar object and a familiar experience.

Why do old things sometimes win over beautiful new ones?

There is another interesting element to our attachment to everyday objects: use gives things meaning.

A new cup may be beautiful, expensive and carefully chosen. But it has no history with you. The old cup may have accompanied hundreds of cups of tea, hurried breakfasts, conversations with family members and quiet mornings when the house was finally still.

The same thing happens with clothes, furniture, books and jewellery. Their value gradually becomes personal rather than financial. Someone else sees an old spoon. You remember the kitchen in which you first used it. Someone else sees a chipped mug. You remember the person who gave it to you. Someone else sees an ordinary steel plate. You remember family meals around a dining table.

The object has become a little marker of your own life.

Familiar objects can give us a sense of continuity

There is perhaps an even deeper reason we become attached to ordinary things as we grow older.

Life keeps changing. Children grow up and leave home. People move from one city to another. Homes change. Relationships change. Our routines change. Even our own bodies change with age.

Against all this change, familiar objects can provide a small sense of continuity.

The same cup sitting in the kitchen cupboard can quietly remind us that some things have remained with us through different chapters of life.

This may be one reason an old family home can feel so different after its familiar objects have been removed. The walls may still be standing, but many of the little visual and sensory reminders that made it home have disappeared.

Our emotional attachment to objects is therefore not necessarily about materialism. Sometimes it is simply about memory and continuity.

And what about that chipped cup?

Of course, there is a practical limit to nostalgia. A cracked cup that is unsafe to use should probably be retired, however many memories it carries. Sentiment is lovely, but it should not defeat common sense.

But if an object is merely old, slightly worn or no longer fashionable, perhaps we don't always need to replace it.

We live in a world that constantly encourages us to buy newer things. New designs arrive every season. Old objects are easily replaced. Sometimes, however, the older object has something the new one cannot possibly have on its first day: a relationship with us.

That relationship is built slowly, through hundreds of ordinary moments.

Perhaps that is why we keep reaching for the same cup every morning. It isn't really about the cup. It is about the familiarity of the ritual, the memories attached to it and the small feeling of comfort that comes from holding something that has been part of our lives for a long time.

So the next time you find yourself choosing the old spoon over the new one, or the slightly chipped cup over the beautiful set that sits untouched in the cupboard, don't dismiss it as a silly habit.

There may be a perfectly human reason for it.

After all, some of the things that make a house feel like home are not the expensive ones. Sometimes they are the humble spoon, the old steel glass, the favourite plate and that one cup that somehow makes the morning tea taste just right.

Neerja Bhatnagar

If you're looking for interesting and effective content on mental health, parenting, lifestyle, reviews, and more, consider subscribing to my other blog, Neerja's Musings.

Feel free to connect with me on social media to stay up to date on more content like this.

Instagram | Facebook | YouTube |Twitter |Podcast

I have written 3 solo books and 3 anthologies. You can buy my books on Amazon. If you are on Kindle Unlimited, you can read them for free. Pls, do check and share your reviews.